Thoughts, and actionable insight
into the science of
Email Verification & Deliverability

Fake Signup Detection

Fake Signup Detection: Protecting Your Lists From Bots, Traps, and Risky Accounts

Published: 12/4/2025

Why detecting fake signups is critical for deliverability, engagement, and reputation—and how Impressionwise keeps your email program safe.

Not all subscribers are real.

Some sign up multiple times. Some are bots. Some are traps. Some are malicious attempts to harm your deliverability.

Fake signups may appear valid but silently erode sender reputation, increase bounce rates, trigger spam complaints, and thwart warm-ups.

The first step to healthy email programs is detecting these fake signups before they enter your campaigns.

This article explains the anatomy of fake signups, why they are dangerous, and how Impressionwise prevents them from affecting your inbox placement and revenue.


What Are Fake Signups?

Fake signups are email addresses or profiles that:

  • are created by bots or scripts
  • intentionally target businesses for spam traps or phishing
  • are recycled, temporary, or disposable
  • mimic real users but never engage
  • originate from suspicious sources

They are not real subscribers and often evade traditional verification tools.


Why Fake Signups Are Dangerous

Fake signups damage campaigns by:

  • increasing bounce rates
  • lowering engagement metrics
  • harming sender reputation
  • triggering domain or IP throttling
  • creating warm-up instability
  • elevating spam complaints
  • introducing compliance risks

Even a small percentage of fake signups can cause disproportionate damage to deliverability.


Common Types of Fake Signups

1. Bot Signups. Automated scripts filling forms for testing, scraping, or malicious purposes.

2. Disposable & Temporary Emails. One-time-use addresses designed to avoid engagement.

3. Spam Traps. Addresses created specifically to catch negligent senders.

4. Recycled or Abandoned Addresses. Old addresses that look valid but are inactive or reassigned.

5. Malicious Signups. Users attempting to trigger spam complaints, degrade reputation, or bypass opt-in mechanisms.


Behavioral & Engagement Indicators

Fake signups often exhibit:

  • no opens or clicks after signup
  • immediate inactivity
  • multiple signups from same IP or domain
  • unrealistic behavior patterns (e.g., rapid navigation, form completion anomalies)
  • high deletion or non-engagement signals

Behavioral analytics are essential to detect fakes before sending.


Source & Acquisition Risk Signals

Fake signups correlate with weak acquisition channels:

  • unverified third-party lists
  • weak or invisible opt-in forms
  • scraped or harvested addresses
  • automated bot submissions
  • poor partner feeds

Evaluating source integrity helps prevent fake signups at the point of acquisition.


Trap & Toxic Email Risk

Fake signups increase the risk of:

  • Spam Traps: Triggering a trap can damage domain reputation instantly.
  • Toxic Profiles: Low-quality or malicious addresses reduce engagement and lower deliverability.
  • Domain/IP Throttling: Multiple risky signups from a single domain or IP can create throttling or blocking events.

Even a small number of fakes can have cascading negative effects.


How Impressionwise Detects Fake Signups

Impressionwise prevents fake signups using a multi-layer predictive framework:

1. Behavioral Analytics

  • detects anomalies in signup patterns
  • flags bots and rapid form completions
  • monitors inactivity risk

2. Trap & Risk Screening

  • identifies spam traps, recycled addresses, and toxic domains
  • suppresses risky signups before campaign entry

3. Source Verification

  • analyzes acquisition channels for quality and risk
  • blocks weak or high-risk sources

4. Predictive Risk Scoring

  • assigns risk scores based on behavioral and source factors
  • prevents high-risk emails from entering active lists

This proactive approach protects inbox placement, engagement, and sender reputation.


Preventing Fake Signups With Best Practices

✔ DO:

  • implement bot-detection mechanisms on signup forms
  • use CAPTCHA or invisible validation
  • verify sources before accepting signups
  • suppress high-risk or suspicious addresses automatically
  • monitor engagement patterns closely
  • segment new signups for risk observation

✘ DON’T:

  • assume verification alone catches fakes
  • rely on third-party lists without quality checks
  • ignore inactivity or behavioral anomalies
  • allow bulk or rapid signups without monitoring
  • send to all new signups immediately without risk screening

Final Recommendations

Fake signups are a silent destroyer of deliverability and engagement. By understanding their anatomy and using predictive, behavioral, and source-level detection tools, you can:

  • protect your sender reputation
  • maintain high inbox placement
  • prevent traps and toxic addresses
  • improve engagement and revenue

Impressionwise identifies and blocks fake signups before they affect your campaigns—ensuring safe, high-performing email programs.

Ensure every email in your list is a real opportunity to connect.

Stop wondering and start knowing what sets Impressionwise apart from other service providers and why top marketers overwhelmingly choose Impressionwise. Sign up now to evaluate our list cleaning services by offering a complimentary scan and report for a sample set of your data to illustrate the benefits of our services. No credit card required, zero obligations.

Try it Now
This website uses cookies and other tracking technologies to enhance user experience, display targeted ads, and to analyze performance, user activity, and traffic on our website according to the Privacy Policy.
Accept
x

Before you head out…

Stop wondering and start knowing if your emails are safe and deliverable.

Experience Impressionwise's industry leading

Try for Free

No credit card required.  |  Zero obligations.